• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Casa de Pasta: An Idyllic Italian Dining Experience in Randolph, NJ

Casa de Pasta, located at 1438 Sussex Turnpike in Randolph, NJ, has been a beloved dining destination since 1983. The charming, vintage aesthetic enhances its inviting ambiance. Guests rave about the friendly, team-oriented service, making each visit feel personal and warm. The menu features a delightful range of Italian classics. Standout dishes include hearty Chicken Parmesan and creamy Tortellini Alfredo, along with crispy Bavarian pretzels. Both first-time and regular diners praise the quality and consistency of the food, emphasizing its cozy atmosphere and reliable service. Overall, Casa de Pasta is an Italian gem worth revisiting for a comforting meal.

Casa de Pasta at a glance

  • Address 1438 Sussex Turnpike, Randolph, NJ 07869, United States
  • Phone +1 973-584-3700
  • Restaurant type Italian restaurant , Family restaurant , Seafood restaurant , Steak house , Wine bar .
  • Popular for Popular for lunch , Popular for dinner , Good for solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

Casa de Pasta: Reviews & Ratings

Christina Aiazzone
4

As others have said, it's a quaint place that has not been updated probably since it's been open in 1983 but that's what gives it its charm. Multiple waitress waited on our table. I liked the team effort. 4% credit card fee. Extra charge for blue cheese dressing. Food was decent. We got mozzarella sticks as an appetizer, they're not homemade but are of the higher end of brought mozzarella sticks. Chicken parm was two big pieces of chicken, just wish there was more cheese. Side of penne vodka was good and my husband enjoyed his tortellini Alfredo.

Kellie Cofrancesco
5

This place is amazing! Ashley and Celia are rock stars and the food is just as amazing as they are! Perfect night out!

Casey James Scheiner
5

Came here on Saturday for a nice dinner, very surprised my wife never ate here before despite passing it for most of her life. Food: we ended up going with a Bavarian pretzel as an appetizer which was an awesome decision, but super filling. I ordered the stuffed shells and my wife got an eggplant dish which were both superb. Aesthetic: deceivingly nice, both small looking but seats a lot of people, and cool bar set up. Service: even though we were thrown in the side room, our waitress was quick to help us out once she realized that we were seated back there. Really good teamwork between all of the waitresses.

Kelly Brown
5

Really delicious food here and the service is great!

Carla Acosta
5

Great and cozy place to get Italian foo. We tried their Clams, Carbonara pasta and chicken. They also offer different drink options and desert.

Alan Pfersch (Al)
5

Always very good. Tried something new this time. Shrimp Matteo with prosciutto and mozzerella. Yum.

Christina Gomez
5

Had a wonderful experience. First time going and we were not disappointed. Staff was attentive and helpful.

beerventurers
5

We ordered trays of chicken, sausage and pasta for a 70 person party and was not disappointed. The quality and quantity was on point at an affordable cost considering the area we live. Everything was fresh and ready to pick up at the agreed upon time. We will certainly be ordering from here again for our next party!

Location

  • Casa de Pasta
    Casa de Pasta
    1438 Sussex Turnpike, Randolph, NJ 07869, United States Hotline: +1 973-584-3700

Welcome to Casa de Pasta, a charming gem nestled in the heart of Randolph, New Jersey. Established in 1983, this quaint Italian eatery offers not only a nostalgic vibe but also a delightful array of dishes that embody the essence of authentic Italian cuisine. Located at 1438 Sussex Turnpike, Casa de Pasta provides a cozy atmosphere perfect for a family dinner or a casual night out with friends.

As you step inside, you'll feel immediately transported back in time. The decor may not have seen many updates, but this adds to the restaurant's unique charm. Multiple waitstaff work seamlessly as a team to ensure your dining experience is enjoyable, allowing for quick service even when the restaurant is bustling.

The menu at Casa de Pasta features a variety of enticing dishes. Guests rave about their appetizers, with the Bavarian pretzel and mozzarella sticks often highlighted. Although the latter are not homemade, they are of a quality that satisfies even the most discerning palates. The main courses continue to impress, with standout items like the chicken parmesan—featuring hearty portions—and a delicious side of penne vodka that perfectly complements the flavors. For those seeking something different, the stuffed shells and eggplant dishes come highly recommended.

Diners appreciate not just the food but the exceptional service from staff members like Ashley and Celia, described as "rock stars." This teamwork enhances the overall dining experience, making you feel well taken care of throughout your visit. The restaurant's capacity might surprise you; while it looks small from the outside, it accommodates plenty of guests with an inviting bar setup.

Casa de Pasta is more than just a restaurant; it's a place where every meal feels like a celebration. Whether you are indulging in a comforting carbonara or savoring the fresh clams, the flavors here tell a story that keeps diners coming back for more. With great food and a warm atmosphere, Casa de Pasta is truly a must-visit destination in Randolph.

To enjoy the delightful offerings of Casa de Pasta, call them at +1 973-584-3700 to make a reservation. You won't be disappointed!

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Has wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Has wheelchair-accessible seating
    • Has wheelchair-accessible toilet
  • Service options
    • Offers takeaway
    • Serves dine-in
  • Payments
    • Accepts credit cards
    • Accepts debit cards
    • Accepts NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards